Conduct of Members Committee
11/06/2025
Candidate PEAKE, Jak in HE Black Other
Candidate COURTENAGE, Simon in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate MILES, Laura in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate RAJYAGURU, Nitin in FE Black Other
Candidate NECKLES, Dr Themesa Y in HE Black Woman
Candidate FLISSI, Safia in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate MCCONNELL, Angie in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate MACMASTER, Rob in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate CAMPBELL, Ray in HE Black Other
Candidate ROCHE, Patricia in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate GOW, Ann in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate EVANS, Peter in FE Non-Black Other
Candidate PAINE, Christina in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate WOODMAN, Sophia in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate MILNER, Julie in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate FIDDLER, Martin in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate MORECROFT, Sam in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate CHUHAN, Dharminder Singh in FE Black Other
Candidate KANE, Lesley in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate OLDHAM, Andrew in FE Non-Black Other
Candidate TOOLE, Suzi in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate WILD, Richard in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate BROWNING, Philippa in HE Non-Black Woman
Candidate ALI, Umran in HE Black Other
Candidate SPEARS, Joshua in FE Non-Black Other
Candidate FONES, John in FE Non-Black Other
Candidate KELSALL, Helen in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate NICOLE, Denis A in HE Non-Black Other
Candidate FARRAR, Janet in FE Non-Black Woman
Candidate ORFITELLI, Robyn in HE Non-Black Woman
FE Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Black Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Black Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
FE Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Woman Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Black Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Black Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Woman Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 11 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
FE Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Other Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Black Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Black Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
HE Black Other Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
FE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
FE Black Max decreased to 2 = sum of subgroup maxima on Gender
HE Black Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on Gender
FE Non-Black Min increased to 3 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Woman Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Black Woman Max decreased to 1 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Non-Black Woman Min increased to 1 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Other Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Black Other Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Black Other Min increased to 1 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 8 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Black Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Non-Black Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Non-Black Min increased to 5 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
Woman Max decreased to 10 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Other Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME

Excluding KELSALL, Helen
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Stage 1
Quota = 21.17

EVANS, Peter ELECTED 
with 45.00
over quota 21.17
 
FE Woman Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Group FE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 5
FE Other Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Non-Black Other Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 8 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Other Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Woman Max decreased to 9 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Group FE Non-Black Other elected increased to 1

ORFITELLI, Robyn ELECTED 
with 42.00
over quota 21.17
 
HE Non-Black Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Woman Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
HE Other Max decreased to 5 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 5 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 8 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
FE Max decreased to 10 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Group HE Non-Black Woman elected increased to 1

WOODMAN, Sophia ELECTED 
with 37.00
over quota 21.17
 
HE Non-Black Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Woman Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
HE Other Max decreased to 4 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 7 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 4 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 7 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
FE Max decreased to 9 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Group HE Non-Black Woman elected increased to 2

Vote required for election now: 21.17

Stage 2
No candidates can be excluded, so we transfer the largest surplus
Surplus of EVANS, Peter
45 papers transferred.
Total Present Value: 45.00
0 papers non-transferable.
Papers transferred at 0.52

MILES, Laura ELECTED 
with 24.84
over quota 21.17
 
HE Non-Black Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Woman Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
HE Other Max decreased to 3 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 3 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
HE Black Max decreased to 3 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Min increased to 6 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Woman Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Other Max decreased to 8 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
FE Max decreased to 8 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Black Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Group HE Non-Black Woman elected increased to 3

Vote required for election now: 21.12

Stage 3
No candidates can be excluded, so we transfer the largest surplus
Surplus of ORFITELLI, Robyn
41 papers transferred.
Total Present Value: 41.00
1 papers non-transferable.
Papers transferred at 0.50
Vote required for election now: 21.07

Stage 4
No candidates can be excluded, so we transfer the largest surplus
Surplus of WOODMAN, Sophia
37 papers transferred.
Total Present Value: 37.00
0 papers non-transferable.
Papers transferred at 0.42

NECKLES, Dr Themesa Y ELECTED 
with 25.78
over quota 21.17
 
HE Black Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Non-Black Max decreased to 5 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Woman Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Black Woman Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
HE Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 5 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Other Max decreased to 2 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Black Other Max decreased to 4 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
HE Black Other Max decreased to 2 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 2 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Woman Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Other Max decreased to 7 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
FE Max decreased to 7 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Group HE Black Woman elected increased to 1

Vote required for election now: 21.02

Stage 5
No candidates can be excluded, so we transfer the largest surplus
Surplus of NECKLES, Dr Themesa Y
34 papers transferred.
Total Present Value: 14.28
0 papers non-transferable.
Papers transferred at 0.13
Vote required for election now: 20.99

Stage 6
No candidates can be excluded, so we transfer the largest surplus
Surplus of MILES, Laura
42 papers transferred.
Total Present Value: 21.84
0 papers non-transferable.
Papers transferred at 0.08
Vote required for election now: 20.95

Stage 7
Tie
involving
OLDHAM, Andrew
TOOLE, Suzi
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
FE Woman Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Group FE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 4

Excluding TOOLE, Suzi
 
Stage 8
There are no outstanding surpluses, and OLDHAM, Andrew, with 0.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
FE Other Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Group FE Non-Black Other candidates decreased to 3

Excluding OLDHAM, Andrew
 
Stage 9
Tie
involving
GOW, Ann
MILNER, Julie
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 7

Excluding GOW, Ann
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 10
There are no outstanding surpluses, and MILNER, Julie, with 1.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
FE Woman Max decreased to 3 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
FE Other Min increased to 2 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
Group FE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 3

Excluding MILNER, Julie
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 11
Tie
involving
COURTENAGE, Simon
BROWNING, Philippa
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Other candidates decreased to 5

Excluding COURTENAGE, Simon
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 12
There are no outstanding surpluses, and BROWNING, Philippa, with 3.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 6

Excluding BROWNING, Philippa
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Vote required for election now: 20.80

Stage 13
There are no outstanding surpluses, and CAMPBELL, Ray, with 3.50 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Black Other candidates decreased to 2

Excluding CAMPBELL, Ray
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Transferring papers worth 0.50
Vote required for election now: 20.73

Stage 14
There are no outstanding surpluses, and NICOLE, Denis A, with 4.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Other candidates decreased to 4

Excluding NICOLE, Denis A
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 15
There are no outstanding surpluses, and ROCHE, Patricia, with 4.42 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Gender
FE Woman Max decreased to 2 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 7 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
FE Other Min increased to 3 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
Woman Max decreased to 8 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Other Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Group FE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 2

Excluding ROCHE, Patricia
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Transferring papers worth 0.42
 
Stage 16
Tie
involving
MACMASTER, Rob
FIDDLER, Martin
 
Tie broken by looking at earlier stages.
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Other candidates decreased to 3

Excluding MACMASTER, Rob
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 17
There are no outstanding surpluses, and FIDDLER, Martin, with 5.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Other candidates decreased to 2

Excluding FIDDLER, Martin
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Vote required for election now: 20.59

Stage 18
There are no outstanding surpluses, and MCCONNELL, Angie, with 6.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 5

Excluding MCCONNELL, Angie
Transferring papers worth 1.00
 
Stage 19
There are no outstanding surpluses, and KANE, Lesley, with 7.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
HE Woman Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Woman Max decreased to 7 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Other Min increased to 4 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
Group HE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 4

Excluding KANE, Lesley
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Vote required for election now: 20.30

MORECROFT, Sam ELECTED 
with 21.02
over vote required 20.30
 
HE Non-Black Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Other Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
HE Black Other Max decreased to 1 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Other Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
HE Min increased to 5 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
HE Black Max decreased to 2 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
Non-Black Min increased to 7 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Black Other Max decreased to 3 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
FE Max decreased to 6 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Black Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Group HE Non-Black Other elected increased to 1

Vote required for election now: 20.18
 
Transferring papers worth 0.50
 
Stage 20
There are no outstanding surpluses, and ALI, Umran, with 8.00 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
Group HE Black Other candidates decreased to 1

Excluding ALI, Umran
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Vote required for election now: 19.52
 
Transferring papers worth 0.50
 
Stage 21
There are no outstanding surpluses, and FARRAR, Janet, with 9.42 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
FE Non-Black Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on Gender
FE Woman Max decreased to 1 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
FE Other Min increased to 4 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
FE Black Other Min increased to 1 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Non-Black Other Min increased to 2 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Black Min increased to 1 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
Woman Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Other Min increased to 5 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Non-Black Other Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Group FE Non-Black Woman candidates decreased to 1

Excluding FARRAR, Janet
Transferring papers worth 1.00
Vote required for election now: 18.85

FONES, John ELECTED 
with 19.50
over vote required 18.85
 
Group FE Non-Black Other elected increased to 2

Vote required for election now: 18.72
 
Transferring papers worth 0.50
Transferring papers worth 0.42
 
Stage 22
There are no outstanding surpluses, and RAJYAGURU, Nitin, with 9.52 has fewest votes and is therefore excluded.
 
Examining effect of exclusion on constraints
CHUHAN, Dharminder Singh guarded 
FLISSI, Safia guarded 
SPEARS, Joshua guarded 
Group FE Black Other candidates decreased to 1
FE Black Max decreased to 1 = sum of subgroup maxima on Gender
FE Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
HE Min increased to 6 = supergroup minimum on Sector - sum of other group maxima
Black Max decreased to 3 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Non-Black Min increased to 8 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Non-Black Min increased to 4 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
FE Non-Black Woman Min increased to 1 = supergroup minimum on Gender - sum of other group maxima
FE Woman Min increased to 1 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
FE Other Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Black Other Max decreased to 2 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
FE Non-Black Other Min increased to 3 = supergroup minimum on BAME - sum of other group maxima
Woman Min increased to 5 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Other Max decreased to 6 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Non-Black Other Min increased to 4 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector

Excluding RAJYAGURU, Nitin
Transferring papers worth 1.00

PEAKE, Jak ELECTED 
with 19.84
over vote required 18.72
 
PAINE, Christina excluded
WILD, Richard excluded
HE Black Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on Gender
HE Non-Black Max decreased to 4 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 3 = supergroup maximum on Gender - sum of other group minima
Group HE Black Other elected increased to 1
Black Min increased to 3 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Non-Black Max decreased to 8 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
HE Woman Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on BAME
Non-Black Woman Max decreased to 4 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
HE Other Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on BAME
Black Other Min increased to 2 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector
Non-Black Other Max decreased to 4 = supergroup maximum on BAME - sum of other group minima
HE Non-Black Other Max decreased to 1 = supergroup maximum on Sector - sum of other group minima
Woman Max decreased to 5 = sum of subgroup maxima on Sector
Other Min increased to 6 = sum of subgroup minima on Sector

Vote required for election now: 18.44
 
***Finished***